Good and bad ways to learn

anonymous kid in helmet riding run bike on pavement in countryside

Learning a new skill is hard. Part of what’s so hard about it is, by definition, you don’t know the skill and so you also don’t know the best way to go about learning it. So you rely on people who do know that skill to guide you through the process. Maybe you’re a child, relying on your parents to teach you how to ride a bicycle. Or maybe you’re an adult who just Googled “how to learn to code.”

Unfortunately, most people who know things are not good at teaching them. Learning a skill and teaching that skill are two separate abilities. Often we learn things and then forget just how we came to understand them.

Emily Oster recently discussed balance bikes vs training wheels for learning to cycle. A balance bike is a bike without pedals that a child can push around with their feet. The research on learning to cycle in these two different ways is light, but Oster quotes a Portuguese study that says kids who use balance bikes learn to ride around age 4 while kids who use training wheels don’t manage until age 6. (The study didn’t establish causality, but I think it’s probably causal.)

Training wheels and balance bikes are both part of the same essential learning strategy: start with a simplified version of the thing you want to learn so you can learn specific parts of it and ignore the other parts. The difference is that training wheels remove the balancing part of cycling to focus on pedaling, while balance bikes remove the pedaling part of cycling to focus on balancing. I think balance bikes are better because staying balanced on a moving bicycle is more important than being able to pedal. Knowing how to pedal is no good if you fall off the bike. If you can coast on a bicycle without falling off, you have plenty of time to learn to pedal.

Last year I tried learning to code in Solidity, the programming language used to write Ethereum smart contracts. I already know how to program in R and Python, so I figured it wouldn’t be too hard to learn another programming language. I found a series of tutorials and slavishly followed them. In the end, I learned…nothing. I couldn’t program in Solidity.

(more…)

The post Good and bad ways to learn appeared first on The Economics Detective.

What learn-to-code websites can teach us about the future of education

I’ve spent most of my life in school. Mostly as a student but occasionally as a TA or prof. Since finishing my PhD this year and striking out into the private sector, I’ve done a little work to beef up my technical skills. I went on one of those learn-to-code websites to practice writing SQL queries, which I haven’t had to use for several years.

I’m not exaggerating when I say that those free websites are already much better at teaching than any university course. And it’s not even close.

But why? Why is traditional classroom pedagogy falling behind online tools? And what can schools learn from this?

(more…)

The post What learn-to-code websites can teach us about the future of education appeared first on The Economics Detective.

Thoughts on Parenting (Before Becoming a Parent)

My wife and I are having a baby. He is due in a little over a month. So before we start this journey, I’d like to write down some of my thoughts, beliefs, and opinions about parenting. Since I’m not yet a parent, these thoughts are primarily influenced by books, intuition, and my observations of friends with small children. I plan on looking back on this post in a year or two to see how the actual experience of parenting changes my views.

There are three books that have had a large impact on my views on parenting, and I’d like to mention them upfront. The first is Bryan Caplan’s Selfish Reasons to Have More Kids. In this book, Bryan uses evidence from twin and adoption studies to argue that parenting is less important to children’s adult outcomes than most people believe. His conclusion is that parents can give themselves permission to not stress out about raising a little future CEO. Instead, parents can focus on doing things that make life more enjoyable for themselves and their kids right now.

The second book that influenced me is Emily Oster’s Cribsheet. This is a data-driven look at many different aspects of parenting. Unlike Caplan, Oster isn’t pushing a specific point. Instead, she gives a broad overview of what the science says about many different areas of parenting, from breastfeeding, to sleep training, to daycare.

The third book I want to mention is not by an economist: Bringing Up Bébé by Pamela Druckerman. This book presents an autobiographical narrative about the American author’s experience raising her kids in France. What’s so interesting about this book is that it illustrates a lot of cultural differences in parenting styles and outcomes. When every kid in your culture is raised in a certain way, it’s hard to distinguish what is and isn’t a human universal, so an intense case study of just one other culture is enough to dispel a lot of false assumptions.

I’ll share my thoughts about parenting, starting general and getting more specific.

(more…)

The post Thoughts on Parenting (Before Becoming a Parent) appeared first on The Economics Detective.